Law Of Large Numbers Catches Up To All Small Insurance Funds
The recent Affordable Care Act (ACA) going live is a reminder of how risk needs to be spread over a large numbers of participants to be viable.
The Law of Large Numbers is one of the concerns that the ACA is not really taking into account. The same thing has happened with many smaller Workers Comp funds nationwide.The Law of Large Numbers is an interesting yet simple way to show how risk needs to be spread over a number of insureds such as in automobile insurance. Workers Compensation requires the same type of larger pool of entrants so that the companies that are experiencing a bad claims year are offset by many safer companies.
There have been many adjustments over the years to guarantee that safe companies are not subsidizing the unsafe ones. The recent move by NCCI to double the primary loss portion of claims was put into place for just that reason. The WCIRB has turned their attention to smaller unsafe companies by removing any small company credits from their X-Mod equation.
Many self-insured funds and pools have felt the bite of The Law of Large Numbers. The pools were initiated with a small group of employers looking to add on others. Unfortunately, the employers had a large enough portion of their pool with bad claims years. The self-insured pool failed as there were too few safe employers in the group.
Many participants in the self-insured pools have felt the sting many years after the funds were shut down due to assessments-after-the-fact. These types of self insurance pools are sometimes covered by any type of insolvency fund as exists with normal WC carriers.
We all shall see how the ACA (Obamacare) makes itself viable. However, one of the main groups that will carry the risk is the younger and healthier segment paying in, but only using a small part of the benefits. Twenty five percent is the projected rate of non-participation. However, the IRS fine is a premium payment of sorts for those 25%.
Carrier or self-insured insolvencies do not seem to be a hot news items as they once were less than 10 years ago. If you are interested in seeing which insurance companies or self-insured pools have become insolvent, there is usually a list provided by the state’s Industrial or Workers Comp Commission.
One great example is the North Carolina list of self-insured insolvencies that you can find here. NCSISA is one of the state associations that actually provide coverage for self-insured bankruptcies resulting in the inability to pay WC claims.
©J&L Risk Management Inc Copyright Notice